• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Aesthetic Realism: Life, Love & Learning

Leila Rosen, English Educator

  • Home
    • About Me
  • Life & Love
    • Being Important: What Does It Mean & What Mistakes Do We Make about It?
    • What Are Women Looking For in Love?
    • What’s Real Intelligence—about Ourselves & the World?
    • What, in a Woman Herself, Interferes with Love?
    • A Woman’s Determination: Right or Wrong?
    • Is Kindness Intelligent, Selfish, Strong?
    • Independence & Need in Our Lives: How Can They Make Sense?
    • Caring for People—Wisdom or Foolishness?
    • Care for Yourself & Justice to Others—Do They Have to Fight?
    • Justice versus Injustice in Men & Women
    • We Want to Be Happy—But Do We Also Want Not to Be?
    • What Does Getting Ahead Really Mean?
    • The Debate in Every Person: To Have More Feeling or Less?
    • True Self-Expression, and What Interferes
    • What Is a Husband’s Biggest Mistake?
    • Can Men & Women Be Intelligent in Love?
    • Everybody’s Big, Dramatic Question: How Much Should People Mean to Us?
    • A Man’s Imagination: What Makes It a Friend or Foe?
    • Individuality and Love: Do They Have to Fight?
    • Public Self & Private Thoughts—Does A Man Have To Pretend?
    • A Woman Whose Name Was Truth
    • Wowing People and Liking Oneself—What Is the Difference?
    • Does Our Anger Weaken or Strengthen Us?
    • What Makes a Man Truly Strong?
    • What Is Woman’s Greatest Victory—Appearing Beautiful or Seeing Beautifully?
    • Is Kindness Strength?—Aesthetic Realism & Thaddeus Stevens
  • Successful Teaching: Here’s How
    • Through Aesthetic Realism Interest Wins, Cynicism Loses
    • On Gogol’s “The Nose,” a Satire on Snobbishness
    • More on the Aesthetic Realism Teaching Method
    • Through the Aesthetic Realism Teaching Method, Knowledge Opposes Anger—and Students Learn!
    • Lessons on Rhyme, Using the Aesthetic Realism Teaching Method
    • Poetry as Justice: Through the Aesthetic Realism Teaching Method, Aesthetics Defeats Contempt
    • Students Choose Knowing the World, Not Fighting with It
  • Language, Literature & Poetry
    • Man Is Poetically Shown in Southern Road, 1932
    • How Musical Can Sadness Be?—or, Grief, Anger, Hope
    • The World Is in Idioms
    • Art Is Within Science
    • Poetry, Atmosphere, and Neatness
    • Some Poetry Is Distinguished
    • The Old Wives’ Tale, by Arnold Bennett
    • A Thrilling Talk on Literature, by Sheldon Kranz
    • Favorite Links about Literature & Teaching English
    • Literature & Life: A Blog
  • Notable Men & Women
    • Spencer Tracy
    • Elizabeth Palmer Peabody
    • Independence & Need in Our Lives: How Can They Make Sense?
    • Justice versus Injustice in Men & Women
    • The Debate in Every Person: To Have More Feeling or Less?
    • True Self-Expression, and What Interferes
    • A Woman Whose Name Was Truth
    • Is Kindness Strength?—Aesthetic Realism & Thaddeus Stevens
  • Blog: Literature & Life
  • Links–& More
    • Photos & Travel
      • Dominican Republic
      • Mississippi
      • Italy, 2012
      • Puerto Rico, 2016
      • Maine
      • Water and land, East Coast
      • Near home
      • Alaska
      • Utah
      • Photographs from some of my travels
      • Cities
    • To find out more about Aesthetic Realism
    • “Timothy Lynch Represents America”

Reading Pickwick, again—& loving it!

July 14, 2014 by leirose

It’s probably been about 25 years since I first read The Pickwick Papers—one of Charles Dickens’ most delightful works. I can remember particular scenes so well, and some of his immortal characters, such as Alfred Jingle, the fat boy Joe, Sam Weller, Mr. Perker, and, of course, Mr. Pickwick himself—are alive in my mind as if I’d just met them for the first time.

Educator Eli Siegel spoke often about this great novel. In one lecture I had the pleasure of hearing, he spoke about how it stirred people when it was published: “The effect of the The Pickwick Papers on the public of then is one of the mighty things in man’s history. People felt this was different: there was a kind of laughter in this work that was different from previous laughter.”

I’d thought about assigning Pickwick to my high school English classes, but its episodic nature—and certainly its length too—kept me from doing so. I did, however, discuss excerpts on many occasions for various reasons. One reason was to have my students understand parallel construction, which Dickens used often and well. Here’s one (very famous) excerpt I especially liked discussing—and even my tough NYC high school juniors and seniors liked it very much. It’s from early in the book:

There are very few moments in a man’s existence when he experiences so much ludicrous distress, or meets with so little charitable commiseration, as when he is in pursuit of his own hat. A vast deal of coolness, and a peculiar degree of judgment, are requisite in catching a hat. A man must not be precipitate, or he runs over it; he must not rush into the opposite extreme, or he loses it altogether. The best way is to keep gently up with the object of pursuit, to be wary and cautious, to watch your opportunity well, get gradually before it, then make a rapid dive, seize it by the crown, and stick it firmly on your head; smiling pleasantly all the time, as if you thought it as good a joke as anybody else.

The Aesthetic Realism Teaching Method, which I used for nearly three decades, is based on this central principle: “The world, art, and self explain each other: each is the aesthetic oneness of opposites.” The opposites most clearly together in parallel construction are sameness and difference, unity and variety, continuity and change. As different ideas are expressed with the same grammatical structure, we feel a coherence, a continuity, between or among them. Yet within even the same structure (as in the pronoun+verb+adverb phrase+adjective+noun in “he experiences so much ludicrous distress” and “meets with so little charitable commiseration”), there are nuance, subtle difference, syllabic and rhythmic variety. And with all the difference, the paired (in this instance) structures make for a sense of organization and unity that is very satisfying.

Students can feel—as we all can—that there’s so much going on in their lives, that things change unpredictably, and that there’s no pleasing organization that they can count on. They can also feel there’s too much sameness, and that nothing changes; they’re bored. I find it beautiful, exciting, and so hopeful that we can learn from grammar and from literature—as in this instance of parallel construction in The Pickwick Papers—that opposites don’t have to fight: they can be together in a way that makes us feel good.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Primary Sidebar

“Ethics—Its Power & Beauty”

I love this recent issue of The Right of Aesthetic Realism to Be Known, about a subject that affects us profoundly at every moment of our lives: ethics. And today, people are more conscious of what is ethical than at practically any time, at least in my memory. The lecture on ethics by Eli Siegel which is being serialized, beginning in this issue, is thrilling! Read it here.

Copyright © 2021 · Genesis Sample on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in